Imagine this: you’re lovingly holding your new baby, ready to start your breastfeeding journey. But then, a sharp sting, discomfort, or difficulty latching can make this beautiful moment feel challenging. Many new parents face these very real struggles, and that’s where a breastfeeding nipple shield can sometimes offer a helping hand.
Choosing the right nipple shield can feel like navigating a maze. There are so many brands, sizes, and materials out there, each promising to be the perfect solution. It’s easy to feel overwhelmed, wondering which one will truly help your baby latch better, ease your pain, or support your breastfeeding goals. You want what’s best for you and your little one, but figuring out where to start can be tough.
In this post, we’re going to break down the world of nipple shields. We’ll explore what they are, why they’re used, and most importantly, how to pick the one that’s right for you. By the end, you’ll feel more confident in your choice and ready to make breastfeeding a more comfortable and successful experience.
Top Breastfeeding Nipple Shield Recommendations
No. 1
Medela Contact Nipple Shields, For Breastfeeding Comfort, Size M 20mm, 2ct | Ultra-Thin Soft Silicone, BPA-Free, With Case, For Flat, Inverted, Sensitive Nipples, Latching Support, Maximum Skin-to-Skin
- FROM THE #1 BREAST PUMP BRAND IN US HOSPITALS: These Contact Nipple Shields bring that same care to the moments breastfeeding gets hard - so you and your baby can keep going.
- A LATCH THAT ACTUALLY WORKS: Whether you are dealing with a painful latch or sore skin, these soft and ultra-thin silicone nipple shields are designed to support a more comfortable feeding experience. They help babies achieve a more effective latch, are suitable for flat or inverted nipples, and create a protective barrier that reduces friction so you can continue breastfeeding while your nipples heal.
- PROTECTION WITHOUT THE DISTANCE: Made from ultra-thin, soft silicone, these Contact Nipple Shields help protect your sore or cracked skin, and the cut-out shape keeps baby close with real skin-to-skin.
- SAFE FOR BABY. RELIEF FOR YOU: The BPA-free, taste-free thin silicone helps ensure a comfortable feeding experience for you and your baby. These Contact Nipple Shields are also easy to clean and dishwasher safe for added peace of mind. Feel confident in every feed.
- FIND YOUR FIT, FEEL THE DIFFERENCE: This nipple shield pair is size M (20mm); Contact Nipple Shields also come in S/16mm and L/24mm, so you can match the shield to your body for comfortable skin-to-skin nursing and optimal milk flow. Find your perfect fit with Medela’s Size Guide.
$8.48
Buy on Amazon
SaleNo. 2
Momcozy Nipple Shield, Floral Contact Nipple Shield (1 Pair, 20mm) | Flat or Inverted Nipples, BPA/BPS-Free
- BREASTFEEDING HELPER: Momcozy contact nipple shields have been carefully designed to accommodate and resolve special breastfeeding situations such as flat nipples, excessive milk drainage and inverted nipples, making breastfeeding easier for you.
- Flower Shaped Surface: The unique flower shaped surface nipple shield has a larger coverage surface, fits better to the skin, is not easy to roll the edge off, and the hole diameter is 2mm, so the milk flows smoothly, and you can feed your baby easily. Promotes the bonding experience of breastfeeding.
- Multiple Sizes Available: Momcozy contact nipple shields are available in 1 pairs and 2 pairs of 17mm, 20mm and 24mm, you need to measure your nipple size before purchasing, according to the nipple size to choose the most comfortable nipple shield that fits you and your baby.
- MADE OF 100% ULTRA-THIN SOFT SILICONE: Made of 100% food grade silicone, BPA and BPS free, easy to clean and sterilize for daily use.
- STORAGE CASE: We provide a pink color storage case for you to store and carry. Perfect for traveling and on the go.
No. 3
Lansinoh Contact Nipple Shields for Nursing Mothers, with Case, 2 Count | Ultra-Thin Soft & Flexible Silicone Shields fits 14-16mm (0.55-0.63 inches), for Sensitive Nipples and Latch-On Support
- HELP DURING LATCHING DIFFICULTIES - Helps you continue to breastfeed while latching issues are addressed
- COMFORTABLE – Made of super-soft, ultra-thin, flexible 100% silicone
- SKIN-TO-SKIN - Unique cut-out design maximizes skin-to-skin contact while using the nipple shield
- HYGIENIC CASE - Comes with protective case for convenient storage
- SAFE FOR MOM AND BABY - BPA and BPS Free
$8.49
Buy on Amazon
No. 4
Medela Contact Nipple Shields, For Breastfeeding Comfort, Size S 16mm, 2ct | Ultra-Thin Soft Silicone, BPA-Free, With Case | For Flat, Inverted, Sensitive Nipples | Latch Support, Maximum Skin-to-Skin
- FROM THE #1 BREAST PUMP BRAND IN US HOSPITALS: These Contact Nipple Shields bring that same care to the moments breastfeeding gets hard - so you and your baby can keep going.
- A LATCH THAT ACTUALLY WORKS: Whether you are dealing with a painful latch or sore skin, these soft and ultra-thin silicone nipple shields are designed to support a more comfortable feeding experience. They help babies achieve a more effective latch, are suitable for flat or inverted nipples, and create a protective barrier that reduces friction so you can continue breastfeeding while your nipples heal.
- PROTECTION WITHOUT THE DISTANCE: Made from ultra-thin, soft silicone, these Contact Nipple Shields help protect your sore or cracked skin, and the cut-out shape keeps baby close with real skin-to-skin.
- SAFE FOR BABY. RELIEF FOR YOU: The BPA-free, taste-free thin silicone helps ensure a comfortable feeding experience for you and your baby. These Contact Nipple Shields are also easy to clean and dishwasher safe for added peace of mind. Feel confident in every feed.
- FIND YOUR FIT, FEEL THE DIFFERENCE: This nipple shield pair is size S (16mm); Contact Nipple Shields also come in M/20mm and L/24mm, so you can match the shield to your body for comfortable skin-to-skin nursing and optimal milk flow. Find your perfect fit with Medela’s Size Guide.
$9.99
Buy on Amazon
No. 5
Koala Babycare The Original Silver Nursing Cups - Nipple Shields for Breastfeeding Newborn - Breastfeeding Essentials - Protect and Soothe - Tri-Laminate Silver - Standard Size
- FOR THE PROTECTION AND COMFORT OF SORE AND CRACKED NIPPLES: Nipple shields which soothe irritation and support the comfort of cracked, painful nipples thanks to silver’s natural soothing properties. Our silver nursing pads also protect the delicate nipple area from direct contact with clothing. With Koala Babycare silver nipple cups, you won't risk having to stop nursing your baby out of discomfort or pain.
- NO CREAMS OR LOTIONS NEEDED: Unlike with nipple cream, Koala Silver Cups won’t alter the taste or smell of breastmilk. This is vital in helping the baby latch on to the breast properly. Koala breast pads are completely odourless and can be removed just before breastfeeding.
- COMFORTABLE AND DISCREET TO WEAR: They fit all breast shapes perfectly and are available in two different sizes. Their anatomical design makes them invisible underneath clothes, and so comfortable you can hardly feel they are there. They protect the sensitive nipple area from direct contact with clothing and are worn discreetly and comfortably underneath your bra.
- QUALITY RAW MATERIAL: Koala Silver Nursing Cups are made of 100% sterling 925 silver or in trilaminate silver. 100% quality assurance and Eco-friendly: they can be reused throughout the entire breastfeeding period as well as during future pregnancies (as opposed to single use disposable nursing pads). Size: Regular ø 1.69 in - h 0.25 in; Maxi ø 1.73 in - h 0.47 in.
- EASY TO USE: Apply a drop of breast milk inside the nipple shield cups so they adhere well to your breasts. Place them on your nipples and then put on your bra. Breast milk promotes comfort for sore, cracked nipples, and their anatomical design prevents them from moving around. Start using them a few days prior to the birth as a preventative measure.
No. 6
Medela Contact Nipple Shields, For Breastfeeding Comfort, Size L 24mm, 2ct | Ultra-Thin Soft Silicone, BPA-Free, With Case, For Flat, Inverted, Sensitive Nipples, Latching Support, Maximum Skin-to-Skin
- FROM THE #1 BREAST PUMP BRAND IN US HOSPITALS: These Contact Nipple Shields bring that same care to the moments breastfeeding gets hard - so you and your baby can keep going.
- A LATCH THAT ACTUALLY WORKS: Whether you are dealing with a painful latch or sore skin, these soft and ultra-thin silicone nipple shields are designed to support a more comfortable feeding experience. They help babies achieve a more effective latch, are suitable for flat or inverted nipples, and create a protective barrier that reduces friction so you can continue breastfeeding while your nipples heal.
- PROTECTION WITHOUT THE DISTANCE: Made from ultra-thin, soft silicone, these Contact Nipple Shields help protect your sore or cracked skin, and the cut-out shape keeps baby close with real skin-to-skin.
- SAFE FOR BABY. RELIEF FOR YOU: The BPA-free, taste-free thin silicone helps ensure a comfortable feeding experience for you and your baby. These Contact Nipple Shields are also easy to clean and dishwasher safe for added peace of mind. Feel confident in every feed.
- FIND YOUR FIT, FEEL THE DIFFERENCE: This nipple shield pair is size L (24mm); Contact Nipple Shields also come in S/16mm and M/20mm, so you can match the shield to your body for comfortable skin-to-skin nursing and optimal milk flow. Find your perfect fit with Medela’s Size Guide.
$9.99
Buy on Amazon
SaleNo. 7
Momcozy Nipple Shields for Breastfeeding Newborn, Flower Shaped(1, 24mm)
- BREASTFEEDING HELPER: Momcozy contact nipple shields have been carefully designed to accommodate and resolve special breastfeeding situations such as flat nipples, excessive milk drainage and inverted nipples, making breastfeeding easier for you.
- Flower Shaped Surface: The unique flower shaped surface nipple shield has a larger coverage surface, fits better to the skin, is not easy to roll the edge off, and the hole diameter is 2mm, so the milk flows smoothly, and you can feed your baby easily. Promotes the bonding experience of breastfeeding.
- Multiple Sizes Available: Momcozy contact nipple shields are available in 1 pairs and 2 pairs of 17mm, 20mm and 24mm, you need to measure your nipple size before purchasing, according to the nipple size to choose the most comfortable nipple shield that fits you and your baby.
- MADE OF 100% ULTRA-THIN SOFT SILICONE: Made of 100% food grade silicone, BPA and BPS free, easy to clean and sterilize for daily use.
- STORAGE CASE: We provide a pink color storage case for you to store and carry. Perfect for traveling and on the go.
No. 8
Munchkin Flow 16mm Nipple Shield for Breastfeeding Newborns, Silicone Latch Monitor with Visible Milk Flow Channel, Nursing Support for Sore Nipples
- See Milk Flow While Nursing: Patented nipple shield with built-in channel lets you see breast milk flow, helping reassure moms during early breastfeeding, sleepy feeds, cluster feeds and bottle-to-breast transitions
- Comfortable Silicone Nipple Shield: Thin, flexible 100% food-grade silicone is BPA free and designed for skin-to-skin contact, sore nipple comfort and effective use with flat or inverted nipples
- Latch Support for Newborn Feeding: Breastfeeding nipple shield can help support baby's latch, giving added confidence during uncertain nursing moments
- Easy Sizing Support: Includes 16mm nipple shield with QR and printable measuring directions. Available in 16mm, 20mm, 24mm and 28mm sizes. *Sizing guarantee: If it’s not the right size or fit, call or email Munchkin, and we’ll help find the right size and send a replacement.
- Starter Kit for Home or Travel: Includes Flow nipple shield, storage case that doubles as a steam sterilizer and cleaning syringe to keep the built-in milk channel clean
$29.99
Buy on Amazon
Your Essential Guide to Breastfeeding Nipple Shields
Nipple shields can be a lifesaver for many breastfeeding mothers. They offer a protective barrier between your baby’s mouth and your nipples. This guide helps you find the best nipple shield for your needs.
What to Look For: Key Features of Nipple Shields
When you shop for a nipple shield, keep these important features in mind.
- Shape and Size: Nipple shields come in different shapes and sizes. A good fit is crucial. It should cover your entire nipple and areola. Some shields have cutouts for better baby contact with your skin.
- Thinness: Thinner shields often feel more natural for both you and your baby. They allow for better milk transfer.
- Flexibility: A flexible shield molds better to your breast. This creates a more comfortable and secure fit.
- Ventilation Holes: Small holes in the shield help air circulate. This can prevent moisture buildup and skin irritation.
- Storage Case: A clean case is important for keeping your nipple shields hygienic when not in use.
The Right Materials Matter
The material of your nipple shield affects comfort and safety.
- Silicone: Most nipple shields are made of medical-grade silicone. It’s soft, flexible, and easy to clean. It’s also hypoallergenic, which is good for sensitive skin.
- BPA-Free: Always choose shields made from BPA-free materials. This ensures they are safe for your baby.
What Makes a Nipple Shield Great (or Not So Great)?
Several factors influence the quality and effectiveness of a nipple shield.
- Quality of Silicone: High-quality silicone feels smooth and doesn’t have a strong smell. Cheap silicone might feel sticky or cause irritation.
- Construction: A well-made shield has smooth edges. Rough edges can rub against your skin and cause discomfort.
- Durability: A good nipple shield lasts. It shouldn’t tear or lose its shape easily with regular use and cleaning.
- Ease of Cleaning: You’ll clean your shield often. It should be easy to wash and sterilize.
User Experience and When to Use Them
Many mothers use nipple shields for specific reasons.
- For Sore or Cracked Nipples: If your nipples are painful, a shield acts as a protective layer. It lets you continue breastfeeding without added pain.
- For Latch Difficulties: Sometimes, babies have trouble latching deeply. A shield can help your baby get a better grip. It can also help babies with tongue-tie or a shallow latch.
- For Flat or Inverted Nipples: Shields can help draw out flat or inverted nipples. This makes it easier for the baby to latch on.
- As a Temporary Solution: Nipple shields are often used for a short time. The goal is to help establish breastfeeding. Then, you can gradually wean off them.
Using a nipple shield is a personal choice. They can be a valuable tool for many breastfeeding journeys. Always consult with a lactation consultant if you have concerns.
Your Nipple Shield FAQs Answered
Q: What is a nipple shield?
A: A nipple shield is a thin, flexible barrier worn over your nipple and areola. It helps protect your nipples during breastfeeding.
Q: When should I use a nipple shield?
A: You might use a nipple shield if you have sore nipples, latching problems, or flat/inverted nipples. It can also help if your baby is premature or has a tongue-tie.
Q: What are the most common materials for nipple shields?
A: Most nipple shields are made of medical-grade silicone. It is soft, safe, and easy to clean.
Q: How do I choose the right size nipple shield?
A: The best size covers your entire nipple and areola. Your baby should be able to get a good grip. A lactation consultant can help you find the right fit.
Q: Are nipple shields safe for my baby?
A: Yes, when made from medical-grade, BPA-free silicone, they are safe. They are designed to be used during breastfeeding.
Q: How do I clean a nipple shield?
A: You should wash them with warm, soapy water after each use. Sterilize them regularly by boiling or using a sterilizer.
Q: Can my baby still get enough milk with a nipple shield?
A: Usually, yes. However, thin shields and a good latch help ensure good milk transfer. Watch your baby for signs of satisfaction.
Q: How long should I use a nipple shield?
A: Nipple shields are often a temporary tool. The goal is to use them until breastfeeding is comfortable and well-established. Then, you can try to wean off them.
Q: What are the downsides of using nipple shields?
A: Some potential downsides include a decrease in milk supply if not used correctly, and the baby may become reliant on the shield. It’s important to work towards weaning off them.
Q: Where can I get help if I’m having trouble with my nipple shield?
A: A lactation consultant is your best resource. They can assess your latch, help with shield use, and guide you on weaning.